As your child approaches the end of high school, one of the most critical decisions looming over both of you is how many colleges they should apply to. This question can be fraught with anxiety and uncertainty, with many families juggling the allure of multiple acceptances against the practicalities of time and cost. 

Here, we'll break down the process and offer a balanced approach to building a college application list that is realistic yet ambitious.

Understanding the Types of Colleges

When building a college list, categorizing potential schools into safety, target, and reach categories helps streamline the decision-making process:

Safety Schools: These are colleges where your child's academic credentials (GPA and standardized test scores) are above the average for admitted students. Safety schools should be places your child would be happy attending, and where the financial aspect is feasible without undue strain.

Target Schools: At these colleges, your child fits well within the average range for admitted students’ academic profiles. The likelihood of admission is good, making these schools realistic options that align well with their academic and social preferences.

Reach Schools: These are more selective schools where your child’s credentials are below the average but within an acceptable range. Admissions at these schools are less predictable and often holistic, considering not just academic metrics but also essays, recommendations, and extracurricular contributions. Furthermore, in order to prep for these universities, it might be beneficial to enroll your child in online after-school programs or private tutoring sessions, like Mentor Match.

Optimal Number?

The number of colleges to apply to can vary based on several factors, but a balanced approach typically includes about 8-10 schools. This range allows your child to apply to a mix of safety, target, and reach schools without overwhelming them. Here's why this range is recommended:

Financial Considerations: With application fees ranging from $50 to $100 or more, applying to a large number of schools can become expensive. Focusing on 8-10 allows for careful selection and investment in each application’s quality.

Time and Effort: College applications require significant effort, including personalizing essays to specific colleges. Limiting the number of applications helps maintain the quality of each application and essay, ensuring your child can present their best self to each institution.

Reducing Stress: Applying to too many schools can be overwhelming and stressful for students. A more focused list allows your child to spend more time on each application and reduces the anxiety associated with managing numerous deadlines and requirements.

Common Pitfalls in the Process

When determining the number of colleges to apply to, several common mistakes can lead to unnecessary complications:

Overreaching: Some families encourage applying to numerous schools. However, if these schools are highly selective, it can set up unrealistic expectations and lead to disappointment. Ensure your child has a balanced list that includes more feasible options as well.

Underestimating Fit: Choosing a college should be about more than just rankings and prestige. Consider factors like the college’s culture, location, size, and the availability of preferred majors. Schools should match your child's academic style and personal interests.

Ignoring Safety Schools: It can be tempting to focus on more prestigious colleges, but safety schools are crucial. They ensure that your child has a good option for college, regardless of how other applications turn out. Make sure these are schools your child would be happy to attend.

Crafting a Balanced College List


To develop a balanced college list, start with a broad range of potential schools and narrow it down through research and reflection:

Begin Broad: Gather information on a wide range of schools that potentially match your child’s interests and abilities.

Visit Schools: If possible, visit campuses to get a feel for the environment. This can significantly impact your child's preferences.

Refine Choices: Use visits, virtual tours, and college fairs to narrow down the list. Focus on where your child feels they could thrive, not just survive.

Balance the List: Ensure there are at least two safety schools, three to four target schools, and a couple of reach schools. This strategy covers different outcomes and keeps options open.

Deciding how many colleges to apply to is a long process that should balance ambition with practicality. A well-considered list of 8-10 schools allows your child to apply to a variety of colleges without spreading themselves too thin. By understanding the types of schools and focusing on creating a balanced list, your child can approach the college application process with confidence, ensuring they find a college where they can flourish.

When your child is eyeing universities, it’s also important to help them prep for what’s to come. We've got just the thing to help them rock those ACTs and SATs—online tutoring platforms like Mentor Match and Khan Academy. Mentor Match hires the top online tutors in the US to offer personalized virtual tutoring sessions designed for your K-12 kid’s goals, whether it’s overall guidance or test prep. Say goodbye to one-size-fits-all tutoring—with Mentor Match, it's all about one-to-one online tutoring tailored to your child's needs."

  • Something bad
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.